case file № 7 · from The Crouches
One word, the wrong state
An Elijah Crouch married in Washington County, Tennessee. Read as Washington County, Pennsylvania, that one word moves a family six hundred miles.
The claim you may have met
That Benedict Crouch of Washington County, Pennsylvania, born in 1800, was the son of Elijah Crouch and Mary Ellis, and through them a grandson of Nathan Crouch of Cecil County, Maryland, and a descendant of the Eastern Shore Crouches of the 1690s.
Where it comes from: a join carried in many online trees and on Find A Grave, built on one name: a county history of 1893 says Benedict's father was called Elijah, and an Elijah Crouch did marry in a Washington County.
What happened
Benedict Crouch is easy to find. Washington County, Pennsylvania holds him twenty-two times over: deeds, a will proved the year he died, an estate file. His father has a name, Elijah, and the name comes from exactly one place. In 1893 a subscription county history printed a sketch of the family supplied by Benedict's own son, and it is there that Elijah appears, with four children: Elisha, Benedict, Stephen and Mary. The county's deeds, wills, estate files, court dockets and tax lists contain no Elijah Crouch at all, and neither does Crumrine's 1882 history of the same county, which knows this family well enough to name four of Benedict's sons.
There is a second Elijah Crouch. He was born in Halifax County, Virginia in 1763, married Mary Ellis, and died in Tennessee in 1825; the two of them lie together at Sinking Creek Baptist Church in Carter County, where she outlived him by twenty-four years. What carries him to Pennsylvania is one word. He married in Washington County — Washington County, Tennessee. Read as Washington County, Pennsylvania, that single word moves a family six hundred miles, and everything above it comes along: an attachment to Nathan Crouch of Cecil County, Maryland, and through Nathan to a documented Eastern Shore family reaching back to the grand jurors of Wicomico Hundred in the 1690s.
The seam shows in the children. As assembled, one woman bore nine of them across four states — Tennessee, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Illinois — over twenty-nine years, and eight of the nine carry no citation of any kind. The 1893 sketch names four of the nine, and the two of those with recorded birthplaces are the two born in Pennsylvania; the five it does not name are the ones born in Tennessee, Maryland and Illinois.
The Maryland half can be tested, and it fails on the single document whose legal function was to state it. When a man dies without a will, the court settling his estate must account for every child, including a child who died before him, whose share passes by name to that child's own children. In June 1838 the orphans' court of Cecil County passed the final account of Nathan Crouch's estate and struck the distribution. It names seven children: Amelia, who married John Scott; Mary, who married Sampson Lum; Rosanne, who married John George; Margaret and Elizabeth, who both married a Joshua Hyland; Rachel, who married Humphry Riddle; and John F. Crouch, the son who administered the estate. Margaret and Rachel were already dead. The court named them anyway and sent their shares down to their five children between them. There is no Elijah on the list, and no issue of an Elijah.
The scan of that page is poor, so I did not see him there would not be enough on its own. The money settles it without reading the list at all. The balance in the administrator's hands was $122.39½ and a share was $17.48½, which is seven shares exactly: six would have left money in the estate and eight would have overdrawn it. A repair was available, and it was declined: invent a Pennsylvania Elijah to hold the join. Adding a person in order to carry a name is the move that built the graft in the first place.
The records, in order
- 1 of 41792THE MARRIAGE
Elijah Crouch and Mary Ellis, married in Washington County — Tennessee.
The right name in a county of the right name, in the wrong state. Both are buried at Sinking Creek, Carter County, Tennessee.
- 2 of 41893THE ONE WITNESS
A county history's sketch, supplied by Benedict's son, names his father as Elijah.
The only source for the name anywhere, and it names no mother. No Elijah Crouch appears in any Washington County, Pennsylvania record series.
- 3 of 4—THE NINE CHILDREN
One couple, nine children, four states, twenty-nine years; eight of the nine without a citation.
Not a family. A merge of at least three.
- 4 of 4Jun 1838THE DISTRIBUTION
Seven children named, two of them dead and named anyway. $122.39½ in hand; $17.48½ a share.
Seven shares exactly. Nobody was lost in the ink, and there is no Elijah.
If your tree carries this line
What would change it
The people in this file
✦ Benedict Crouch (1800–1882)