The Family › Thomas Lewis Latané Temple III › In My Opinion
In My Opinion · Latané Temple
What the Army taught about teaching
Thursday, April 25, 1974 · The Free Press, Diboll, Texas · page 8
Away back in 1942 I went through the officer candidate course at the Infantry School in Ft. Benning, Georgia,—the Thirtieth Company of the Third Student Training Regiment. In other words, we were the ninetieth new company to be constituted and, as it turned out, the last. Since the course was for ninety days (cf. "ninety-day wonder"), this made it possible for the Army to turn out a company of infantry second lieutenants a day. Two hundred a day was a fairly modest number, I venture, since infantry platoon leaders were the most expended human item in the war and replacements were in great demand.
We were taught what you would expect: weapons, map reading, organization, small unit tactics, close order drill, command and the like. But we were taught teaching also.
It was explained to us repeatedly that a platoon leader's second most important responsibility was to lead troops in combat.
Number one was teaching. It was our responsibility to see that the men under us knew first how to take care of themselves in combat, for their lives depended upon their knowing. Beyond that they had to understand discipline and how to take orders — and the why of the requirement. Scouting and patroling, map reading, reporting, chain of command, sanitation, etc. etc.
We were taught the psychology of teaching and methods of teaching. We had to learn explanation, demonstration, and participation as steps in instruction, that is, to tell about the subject, show how it is done and then let the student go through it. Seems to me we were taught that we learn twice as much seeing as we do hearing and twice as much doing as we do seeing. We were instructed by these methods to use these methods. And a whole lot more, of course.
But the most important thing we learned was that we do not learn if we do not want to and the special circumstances of war made this fact exceptionally important— important because our students were draftees, which is to say involuntary pupils. They were not sitting at our feet thirsty for learning. On the contrary, many ranged from indifferent to hostile, jerked out of civilian life into an alien condition.
For those with minds open to learning we had to work to keep them open. For those closed, we had to work to open them.
I had been through high school, actually a prestigious Eastern prep school, and through college. Yet this was a new idea for me. I had had some good instructors and remembered them because I learned from them, but most I had just threw it out for us to get if we could or to fail if we could not. There was some counseling, I guess, in high school, but no big deal.
In the army we were taught to make every step of learning as pleasant and as easy as we could; to be patient; never to use sarcasm; never to make a man feel stupid, for what he learned could save his life, the life of his comrades and the very success of our cause.
I was astonished to recall how these simple rules had been ignored in the school instruction I had received.
I am astonished after five children of my own, the last of which is now a sophomore in high school, how this mandate is still ignored. My wife and I fed them into the system with a healthy respect, I hope, for learning, and have seen them come home hating forever some subjects they signed up for in joyous anticipation. A sarcastic, hard, unsympathetic teacher who took pride in the failures, not the successes, she or he produced was the cause.
Such instruction harms students as surely as if they were being handicapped physically. Sadism has no place in teaching.
Teachers are hired to teach.
About this text
This is his own account, as he printed it in 1974. It has not been checked against the records; the pages for the people he names show what the records support. The text was typed from the newspaper page by machine and compared with the page image line by line, keeping his spellings. A dotted underline marks a word the print leaves in doubt. Cite as LT3-19740425-IMO.
As it was printed
The column as it ran, cut from the newspaper page and stacked in reading order.
