The Family › Thomas Lewis Latané Temple III › In My Opinion
In My Opinion · Latané Temple
Arden House and the presidency
Thursday, January 13, 1977 · The Free Press, Diboll, Texas · page 13
Back in 1960 -- November of 1960 -- I was a guest at Arden House on the Hudson above New York City at a meeting of the American Assembly. The Assembly meets regularly to discuss in an academic atmosphere issues important to our country and brings together individuals out of government, colleges, business and the professions for a three day exchange of ideas, first broken into round tables and, on the last day, a plenary meeting when a consensus statement is worked out.
Arden House is a gift of the Harriman estate to the Assembly. Its support comes from the Rockefeller Foundation. Its governance is in Columbia University.
Those attending when I did included, Averell Harriman, Senator William Benton who finally brought Joe McCarthy low, Dr. Elliott, Eisenhower's economic advisor, James Conant, president of Harvard and others equal. Brewster, president of Dartmouth was my roommate. Mariner Eccles, braintruster under Franklin Roosevelt, was my tablemate and wine host.
The subject of this particular Assembly was The Secretary of State. We were, as is the format, given a volume of reading to do to prepare us. I sat next to a fellow at my table -- this was right after Kennedy had been elected and before he had chosen his cabinet -- a fellow who identified himself to me as a graduate of Davidson University, a past Rhodes Scholar, et cetera. His name was Dean Rusk.
This self-serving preamble leads up to a point. After three days we concluded in substance that the job of Secretary of State was unmanageable, period; that there was no way for an individual moving into the top spot in a fast-moving professional department employing thousands of civil service career people, no way an individual in a department which receives tens of thousands of coded messages in any single day, no way an individual who has myriad ceremonial duties can possibly know what is going on, much less sit back in contemplation to formulate long range policy.
Rusk was soon thereafter appointed Secretary of State, where he served under Kennedy and Johnson. In my judgment he bore out, unfortunately, the conclusions of that Assembly.
What does this have to do with now? Well, what applies to State applies to the Presidency in spades. How can one man moving in at the top of an ongoing, complex, diverse, institutionalized machine like the United States government get a handle on it? God knows I have no answer. I started to say that if I did, I would be president, a misstatement on the face of it, since that would not get me elected and since those who have been elected could not.
However, there is presently, it seems to me, a candle in this gloom. Let me explain myself.
I do not recall a president in my sixty-two years who has before taking office given so much study and contemplation to policy and direction as Carter has. The importance of this is that it may be his last and only chance. From now on after taking office he will, as we used to say when I worked summers in the sawmill, be snatching and grabbing. Or in another figure, he will be fielding hot grounders and line drives, unable to think and plan in perspective.
In these almost three months of grace President-elect Carter has consulted at length with experts in every field of his responsibility. He has even held a meeting of his future cabinet.
Nixon's football metaphors make me choke a little as I perpetuate in my small purview this device, but here goes: Carter has apparently used the calm before his involvement to develop a game plan. Once he and his cabinet are in, the pressures will call the play.
We have to hope that there is a plan within which decisions can be made aiming at something generally good.
Makes me think that it might be a good idea to give an incoming president more like six months instead of three to get his thing together before taking office.
About this text
This is his own account, as he printed it in 1977. It has not been checked against the records; the pages for the people he names show what the records support. The text was typed from the newspaper page by machine and compared with the page image line by line, keeping his spellings. A dotted underline marks a word the print leaves in doubt. Cite as LT3-19770113-IMO.
As it was printed
The column as it ran, cut from the newspaper page and stacked in reading order.
